Blog: Nezua
 
 
See all of Nezua's blog posts
Symbol and Essence: The Vote Version
Posted February 06, 2008 at 9:18 AM

SUPER TUESDAY is over. Today is Non-Super Wednesday. And regardless of which Presidential candidate gathers more delegates in the primary; regardless of who takes the popular vote; regardless, even, of who (and whose agenda) is ultimately voted into the White House in November and how much changes as a result, one truth remains unaffected: The power to make change resides in each and every one of us, and every day.

 

The obligation to work at positive changes in our society on a personal and community level ought not, and in reality, cannot be sublimated into or subsumed by one day in a booth with a button. In Civil Disobedience, Henry David Thoreau reminds us of this.

 

Even voting for the right is doing nothing for it. It is only expressing to men feebly your desire that it should prevail. A wise man will not leave the right to the mercy of chance, nor wish it to prevail through the power of the majority.

 —HENRY DAVID THOREAU, CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE

 

Substitute "human" for "man," and this holds true today. And will always hold true. For our vote is but a symbol of what we hope to see happen in our world. But voting for a winner on American Idol is, in all reality, a more direct expression of a person's will, and has a greater chance of resulting in one's direct wish for a specific outcome.

 

And the danger in getting too caught up in the symbol of the Vote, rather than focusing upon the underlying essence that gives that symbol meaning—making change and affecting the world around us—is the potential abdication of our social and communal obligations.

 

A personal story. My adoptive father was a man who would visit a certain denomination of church every Christmas Eve. He did not live by the tenets of this religion, he did not reflect upon the philosophies of that religion, and he did not carry the idols with him—pictorially, mentally or verbally. He did not visit any other time of year, and when the night was over, he forgot the church until the next Christmas Eve, his duty and observance satisfied. Combine this habit of his with the Superbowl, and you end up with how I see much of the Presidential elections and the related voting we do.

 

The state of the country does not depend on how you vote at the polls, but on how you vote everywhere.

—THOREAU'S JOURNALS; PASSAGES READ BY H.G.O. BLAKE BEFORE THE CONCORD SCHOOL OF PHILOSOPHY.

 

We "vote everywhere" not so much by ballot, or by shopping, or even by blogging. For what is the "state of the country," after all? What is a "country," but a collection of communities? And what is a community, but a collection of people? And if those people (us) do nothing but vote one day of the year, shop, blog, and then leave the state of their (our) culture and society and communities in the hands of the elected officials, what have we done? What have we contributed? What have we affected? I cannot speak for anyone else, but I have an idea (one might say "vision," were s/he not worried about being misunderstood) of the world I want to live in. And I do not feel content to check a box or pull a lever or push a button and hope, somehow, that this action brings that world about.

 

Nor am I content to point my finger at the person sitting in the White House and blame them for all the wrongs that we visit upon ourselves in the form of our actions and non-actions.

 

Must the citizen ever for a moment, or in the least degree, resign his conscience to the legislator? Why has every man a conscience then?

—HENRY DAVID THOREAU, CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE

 

Mahatma Gandhi told us to be the change in the world that we wanted to see. And of course "be" is both a state of existence, as well as a verb.

 

In the current political atmosphere, there is much talk of change (at least on the political Left). There is talk of hope. There is talk of progress. And I respond. Because these are also part of my vision for the world, as well.

 

I am one human, and citizen, who is not content to leave these ideals and goals in the hands of politicians. Every day I want to nurture some hope within myself, and perhaps in someone else, if I can. Every day I hope for positive change, and every day I want to move toward that change. For it is an epic and important work in progress—self and state and nation. And my deepest obligations to my self, my neighbor, my community, my planet, and the future can never be foisted upon government officials far from me—no matter how many people checked a box or pushed a button or pulled a lever in their favor.

 

Men may talk about measures till all is blue and smells of brimstone, and then go home and sit down and expect their measures to do their duty for them.

 

—THOREAU'S JOURNALS; PASSAGES READ BY H.G.O. BLAKE BEFORE THE CONCORD SCHOOL OF PHILOSOPHY.

 

Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday—every day, it is up to me to do my best to live in the essence of what my vote can only hope to symbolize.


 
 
Group
 
   
 
Rate This
3 Ratings
Take Action On
 
 
Tags: change   politics   election   voting   Community   activism   democracy   action   politicians   hope   Street Team 08   Civic Duty   symbolism
Views: 232    Favorited: 1
URL:
 
 
Comments(12)
Post a Comment
Jaime_McLeod 687 days ago

That's some sweet punditry, my man! Who doesn't love a little Thoreau on a  Wednesday morning?

Re: Nezua 687 days ago

Kafka?


 


(thank you!)

monshiprose 687 days ago

I warred with Safari to comment on how much I love this post.  And Safari won, so I'm using Firefox. 


 


The more we talk about politics of change and audacity of hope, the more people need reminders that the change comes with all their actions and choices -- not just going to vote and casting a ballot -- and the hope lives in remaining conscious of the fact actions and choices cause change.  Fighting back helplessness and indifference.  Feet hitting the concrete.  


 


But this is a sweet wrap-up of all of that; kudos.

Re: Nezua 687 days ago
thank you. you are right. without the hope and inspiration, action seems so hard...and often unimportant. but without the action, the feelings aren't much but good feelings.
VASabina 686 days ago

I sweat the graphic! Great blog! Holla at some non-Super state lovin :)

Re: Nezua 686 days ago
:D ah, shux, you rock, Sabina! Thanks.
yave_begnet 686 days ago

Awesome post.  We fancy ourselves to be the beacon of true shining democracy on a thousand hills of light ... or something ... but really, we're a long ways from a meaningful, functional participatory democracy.  Not to mention global democracy, which most people don't even think is possible, much less desirable.  But to hear our politicians and diplomats regurgitate the placatory, condescending tropes about the power of the purple finger that they love, you'd think we were Jesus himself come back in collective form to kick off a thousand year reign (reich? ... have I violated any Viacom no-no's yet--I didn't actually bother to read the terms of participating here.)


 


This by way of saying that when I hear the phrase "audacity of hope," it makes me throw up a little in my mouth.  I voted Obama yesterday, probably for many of the same reasons as others here did or plan to.  I even wrote a post about how he is the choice for migrant advocates on Monday, but I still think if he is elected president, I will likely spend an awful lot of time criticizing him.  Maybe that's just because I'm in my "old and jaded" phase that started sometime last year at 28 and will probably continue until I die.  Is that hopeful enough?  I guess that is the point of Nez's post--look past the fluff, don't accept anything you hear without questioning it, and temper our expectations for others while raising them for ourselves. 

Re: Nezua 686 days ago
beautifully said, yave.

and i have to admit that "power of the purple finger" had me laughing out loud.
Liz_MTV 685 days ago

I love this post, too. We can "hope" all we want, but not much happens unless we actually DO something to improve our communities.

Re: Nezua 685 days ago

i appreciate that a lot, liz. thanks for reading. :)

SaraBenincasaNY 683 days ago

Perfecto.

Re: Nezua 679 days ago
Gracias.