NEWS:  Proposition 8 Challenges To Be Heard In California Supreme Court As Early As March
 
 
Proposition 8 protesters gather in San Francisco on November 15, 2008
Photo: Justin Sullivan/ Getty Images
Nov 20, 2008 10:12 AM
The California Supreme Court has decided it will review challenges to Proposition 8, which bans gay marriage, as early as March.
from  MTVNews
By  Gil Kaufman

A week after thousands took to the streets across the country to protest the passage of California's controversial Proposition 8, which bans gay marriage, the California Supreme Court voted 6 to 1 on Wednesday to review legal challenges to voter initiative as early as March.

The Los Angeles Times reported that while the court did not rule to allow gay marriages to resume as it mulls a final decision, given the complexity of the issue, it did move to act much more quickly on hearing the legal challenges to Prop 8 than legal scholars had expected. Opponents of the measure are seeking to have the court rule to overturn it and reinstate gay marriages in California.

The swiftness of the court's action suggests that it wants to resolve all the legal issues surrounding the proposition, including the fate of existing gay marriages, in one ruling, the Times reported. Some analysts suggested that scheduling a hearing so quickly was a good sign for the challengers, though others said it did not give any indication of which way the court might be leaning.

"If the justices were really leaning towards upholding Prop 8, and that was clear, they would have wanted to do it as quickly as possible and put the issue to rest," UCLA law professor Brad Sears told the paper, adding that the delay could indicate that the justices were divided and needed time to resolve the issues.

While some gay-rights advocates praised the court for acting so quickly to review the measure, others were disappointed that the court did not vote to allow same-sex marriages to resume while awaiting the final ruling. The challengers are seeking to overturn Prop 8 based on a number of arguments, including claims that the provision violated the separation of powers doctrine in the California Constitution and that the measure took away the ability of California courts to ensure equal protection for minorities who have historically suffered discrimination.

On November 4, the state ballot provision amending the state Constitution to restrict the definition of marriage as a union between a man and a woman passed by a 52 to 47 percent margin. Since that day, opponents have filed six lawsuits aiming to overturn the measure.

The passage of Prop 8 came after the Supreme Court of California had overturned the state's ban on same-sex marriage in May, paving the way for thousands of gay couples to legally marry in only the second U.S. state to make marriage licenses available to same-sex partners.

Despite the challenge and possibility of an overturning vote, supporters of Prop 8 applauded the court's action, according to the Times. "We see today as a grand slam," said Andy Pugno, general counsel of ProtectMarriage.com. "Everything we asked for was granted," he added, citing the dissenting judge's vote as an indication that "she thought the lawsuits had ... little merit."

California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger has said he expects the court to overturn the proposition (an outcome he appears to favor), and his office issued a statement saying, "The governor believes the Supreme Court ought to bring clarity to this issue."

 
 
Rate This
0 Ratings
Take Action On
 
 
Tags: Proposition 8   Prop 8   California Supreme Court   gay marriage   ban
Views: 93    Favorited: 0
URL:
 
 
 You are not logged in. Log In or Sign Up
Post a Comment
Related Media
 
See all related
 
   
 
'This Was A Right That Was Taken Away'
Stolz prepares to give a speech at the NYC Prop 8 rally. (11.15.08)
Tags: Rally   MTV News   New York   Gay   civil rights   marriage   Prop 8   Proposition
Views 1
by  MTVNews on november 17, 2008
 
   
 
Kim Stolz Speaks To The New York Prop...
"Is America only willing to accept us on our TV screens and our iPods?" (11.15.08)
Tags: Rally   MTV News   New York   Gay   civil rights   marriage   Prop 8   Proposition
Views 0
by  MTVNews on november 17, 2008
 
   
 
Spencer Pratt Tells Prop 8 Opponents To...
"Heidi's hair and makeup people are some of my favorite homosexuals on the planet," the "Hills" star says. (11.13.08)
Tags: California   MTV News   Gay Marriage   the hills   Heidi Montag   Spencer Pratt...
Views 77
by  MTVNews on november 13, 2008
 
   
 
'Gays And Lesbians Have The Right To M...
Protesters of Prop 8 say gay marriage is, more than anything, a civil-rights issue. (11.7.08)
Tags: California   Protests   Gay Marriage   Proposition 8
Views 64
by  MTVNews on november 07, 2008
 
   
 
'I Don't Understand How People Can Be ...
Christina Aguilera says she supports the Proposition 8 protestors, particularly in a time that's supposedly all about change. (11.7.08)
Tags: Gay   Christina Aguilera   marriage   GLBT   same-sex   Proposition 8   Prop 8
Views 98
by  MTVNews on november 07, 2008
 
   
 
'It Has Nothing To Do With The Children'
Opponents of Prop 8 hit the streets on Election Day in Los Angeles (11.4.08)
Tags: MTV News   Barack Obama   Election 2008   John McCain   Think   Proposition...
Views 66
by  MTVNews on november 04, 2008
 
   
 
'I'm Not In Favor Of Gay Marriage [But] ...
The senator addresses the issue of gay marriage and reviving inner cities. (11.2.08)
Tags: 2008   election   MTV   Gay Marriage   Senator   Barack Obama   show   Ask Obama
Views 109
by  MTVNews on november 02, 2008
 
   
 
7 of 10: Gay Marriage Vs. Civil Unions
While he isn't in favor of gay marriage, Obama does support civil unions that would give same-sex couples the same benefits (2.2.08)
Tags: Muslim   Civil Unions   Gay Marriage   Senator   Barack Obama   Democrat   Economy...
Views 7203
by  MTVNews on february 02, 2008
 
   
 
See us at Prop 8!
This past weekend turned out even greater numbers of communities all over the U.S gathering against the passing of Proposition 8--not just in California, but across...
Tags: equal rights   Prop 8
Views 24
by  Breakthrough on november 17, 2008
 
   
 
MSNBC Keith Olbermann on Prop 8, Mar...
AMAZING!! MSNBC Keith Olbermann comments on Calif. Prop 8, gay rights, marriage, love and more.
Tags: Keith Olbermann   Prop 8
Views 75
by  musicisoxygen on november 13, 2008
 
   
 
Lance Toma urges voters to think critical...
Lance Toma urges voters to think critically about Prop 8.
Tags: politics   California   Same Sex Marriage   discrimination   LGBT   Asians   ...
Views 22
by  Asian & Pacific Islander... on october 28, 2008
 
   
 
Legal For All
Democratic Governor Deval Patrick has signed a measure allowing out-of-state same-sex couples to legally marry in Massachusetts. The Bay State is one of two states...
Tags: election   Gay Marriage   Mitt Romney   Street Team 08   massachusetts   Deval...
Views 151
by  JohnRaphael on august 08, 2008
 
   
 
LGBT Youth and Politics
Teens who identify as either gay or lesbian speak on various issues, including growing up gay in Las Vegas and the 2008 election.
Tags: youth   election   Gay Marriage   Hillary Clinton   obama   gay rights   Gay...
Views 154
by  MiGoNev on july 23, 2008
 
   
 
Iowa Smoking Ban Fair?
State Rep. Janet Peterson is the main sponsor of the Iowa Smokefree Air Act, which went into effect on Tuesday. Jeff Wagner is a bar manager who feels the government...
Tags: smoking   election   Choose Or Lose   health   Iowa   Street Team 08   ban   ...
Views 58
by  NathanLeigh on july 02, 2008
 
   
 
VLOG: Atlantic City's Smoking Ban: Savi...
Street Team Correspondent Sia Nyorkor dishes on the new law that would ban smoking in all 11 of Atlantc City's casinos.
Tags: smoking   New Jersey   Choose Or Lose   law   Street Team '08   Sia Nyorkor...
Views 90
by  SiaNyorkor_NJ on may 01, 2008
 
   
 
Piercings
Depicts body piercings then two female hands with a ring to ask "Who decides where a ring should go?"
Tags: politics   election   vote   Gay Marriage   Choose Or Lose   discrimination
Views 78
by  thinkMTV on march 31, 2008
 
   
 
Lance isn't Smoking
Lance Armstrong visits Madison and Milwaukee this week to promote a state wide smoking ban. Though the issue attracts bipartisan support, not everyone is on board...
Tags: smoking   Democrats   Republicans   wisconsin   rights   Street Team 08   Milwaukee...
Views 267
by  CharlieB on march 06, 2008
 
   
 
Will New Jersey Approve Gay Marriage?
A court took a big step earlier this week by affording gay couples the same rights as married straight couples. (10.30.06)
Tags: Civil Unions   Gay Marriage   New Jersey
Views 2903
by  thinkMTV on september 12, 2007
 
   
 
'I Really Believe Hope ... Watched Over Me'
Max Nitze, 23, explains how his fiancee (and a tattoo in her honor) helped him through his two deployments. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Choose Or Lose Presents Obama...   ...
Views 4938
by  MTVNews on july 06, 2009
 
   
 
The Albers Family House Is Revealed
A home destroyed by Hurricane Katrina is completely renovated and furnished. (1.20.09)
Tags: Sway   Barack Obama   be the change   inauguration   Youth Ball   Huricane...
Views 0
by  MTVNews on january 26, 2009
 
 
News
 
 
 
   
 
by  thinkMTV
"Hills" stars Heidi Montag and Spencer Pratt discussed Proposition 8 and their upcoming "Ho...
 
   
 
by  thinkMTV
Christina Aguilera spoke out against California's Proposition 8 as demonstrators took to the street...
 
 
Groups
 
 
 
   
 
Organized by  CourtneyRoselia
To be clear, this is a group on what individuals views are about the world around us and how...
 
   
 
Organized by  ChristineCummins
We are the people who believe in America and what it can do. We love and appreciate livin...