NEWS:  Connecticut Supreme Court Overturns Gay-Marriage Ban
 
 
Photo: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Oct 10, 2008 02:19 AM
Connecticut became the third U.S. state to allow gay marriage after its Supreme Court ruled that civil unions for same-sex couples were discriminatory.
from  MTVNews
By  Gil Kaufman

Following a 4-3 ruling Friday morning (October 10) by its Supreme Court, Connecticut became the third state in the U.S. to allow gay marriage. Citing the equal-protection clause of the state constitution, the justices in the case ruled that civil unions for gay and lesbian couples were discriminatory and that the state's "understanding of marriage must yield to a more contemporary appreciation of the rights entitled to constitutional protection," according to the Hartford Courant.

"Interpreting our state constitutional provisions in accordance with firmly established equal-protection principles leads inevitably to the conclusion that gay persons are entitled to marry the otherwise qualified same-sex partner of their choice," the majority opinion in the case stated. "To decide otherwise would require us to apply one set of constitutional principles to gay persons and another to all others."

In 2005, Connecticut passed the first civil-union law in the nation that was enacted without a court mandate, and while Governor M. Jodi Rell said she disagreed with the court's decision to overturn the ban on gay marriage, she vowed to uphold it. "The Supreme Court has spoken," Rell said. "I do not believe their voice reflects the majority of the people of Connecticut. However, I am also firmly convinced that attempts to reverse this decision — either legislatively or by amending the state constitution — will not meet with success. I will therefore abide by the ruling."

Opponents of the decision said the court had "usurped democracy" in the state and "redefined marriage by judicial force,'' according to Peter Wolfgang, executive director of the Family Institute of Connecticut. The organization will now join with similar groups to help promote an initiative on the November 4 ballot asking whether the state should convene a constitutional convention to allow "direct initiatives," which would presumably allow anti-gay-rights groups to seek a state constitutional ban on same-sex marriage.

The case stemmed from a group of eight same-sex couples who were unsatisfied with the civil-union decision and sued after being denied marriage licenses in 2004, the Courant reported. Arguing that civil unions already provided all the rights and protection of marriage, the state won the case in a Superior Court ruling in 2006, which the couples appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that civil unions were a "less prestigious, less advantageous institution." Lawyers for the couples also argued that same-sex marriage was a fundamental right guaranteed under the ban on sexual discrimination in the constitution and that the couples were being discriminated against based on sexual orientation.

The Courant reported that the court's ruling will likely be the final judicial judgment on the case because it's based on the state constitution, but opponents could still seek a constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage.

Before Friday's ruling, only Massachusetts and California had allowed same-sex couples to marry. Proposition 8, a ballot initiative that would outlaw same-sex marriages in California, will be put to a vote on November 8. According to The Associated Press, groups supporting the ban have reportedly taken in more than $25 million so far in their efforts to pass the measure, while a number of celebrities — including Fall Out Boy, Brad Pitt and Steven Spielberg — have donated large sums to oppose the ban.

 
 
Rate This
2 Ratings
Take Action On
 
 
Tags: Connecticut   Supreme Court   Overturns   Gay-Marriage   Ban  
Views: 357    Favorited: 2
URL:
 
 
 You are not logged in. Log In or Sign Up
Post a Comment
The Future is Now 409 days ago
There was a time,when I would not dare comment,for I was in the closet.Closets are for clothes. :)


Gloria Gaynor's song,"I am what I am"..says it all.

Peace

LW
Rehoboth Beach,DE USA
Related Media
 
See all related
 
   
 
18 of 21: A President Who Believes In Th...
The senator doesn't have a litmus test for Supreme Court appointees, but they would need to be empathetic. (10.29.07)
Tags: 2008 election   MTV News   Choose Or Lose   MySpace   Presidential Dialogue...
Views 12615
by  MTVNews on october 29, 2007
 
   
 
Thank you Connecticut!
Well, it's time to wrap up this amazing adventure known as Street Team '08. Since my stories depended on the people of Connecticut sharing a slice of their life...
Tags: recycling   election   debate   poverty   Choose Or Lose   gay rights   Connecticut...
Views 58
by  kristendeptula on november 12, 2008
 
   
 
Katherine Salberg
This conservative first time voter is concerned about the reprecussions an Obama presidency would have on the Iraq war and the homosexual movement, and feels it...
Tags: election   Iraq   Choose Or Lose   gay rights   Economy   Connecticut   McCain...
Views 54
by  kristendeptula on november 05, 2008
 
   
 
Valene Fong
This 19 year old mom has strong concerns about Iraq and says she voted for Obama for her daughter's future.
Tags: war   election   Iraq   Choose Or Lose   obama   Connecticut   Street Team 0...
Views 14
by  kristendeptula on november 05, 2008
 
   
 
Keava Bonner
This first time voter knows first hand how the mortgage crisis is impacting families in the state.
Tags: election   Choose Or Lose   Connecticut   Street Team 08   First Time Voter...
Views 9
by  kristendeptula on november 05, 2008
 
   
 
Mark Cooper
This first time voter from Hartford Connecticut has some serious concerns about healthcare.
Tags: election   Choose Or Lose   obama   Healthcare   Connecticut   street team
Views 11
by  kristendeptula on november 05, 2008
 
   
 
Republican Signs
Connecticut is known as a liberal state, but these CT Republicans are making their own statement.
Tags: election   Choose Or Lose   Connecticut   Street Team 08   nobama
Views 18
by  kristendeptula on november 04, 2008
 
   
 
Voters in Ellington Go to the Polls
The Smith/Turkson family explain their choice this election, and why youth are energized by Obama's campaign.
Tags: election   Choose Or Lose   obama   Connecticut   Street Team 08
Views 8
by  kristendeptula on november 04, 2008
 
   
 
Last Call
Volunteers at Obama for America's Connecticut headquarters take to the phones reaching out to voters in swing states in the last weekend of Get Out the Vote efforts...
Tags: election   Choose Or Lose   obama   Volunteers   Connecticut   Street Team ...
Views 31
by  kristendeptula on november 03, 2008
 
   
 
Locals get Political 4
Who needs pre-made signs? While traveling for a story I found some residents had taken the initiative to create their own. Sorry, McCainiacs, I saw no love on...
Tags: politics   election   Choose Or Lose   obama   Connecticut   Street Team 08
Views 10
by  kristendeptula on november 01, 2008
 
   
 
Locals get Political 3
Who needs pre-made signs? While traveling for a story I found some residents had taken the initiative to create their own.
Tags: politics   Choose Or Lose   Connecticut   Street Team 08   signs
Views 15
by  kristendeptula on november 01, 2008
 
   
 
Locals get Political 2
Who needs pre-made signs? While traveling for a story I found some residents had taken the initiative to create their own. Sorry McCainiacs, I saw no love out...
Tags: politics   election   Choose Or Lose   Connecticut   street team
Views 7
by  kristendeptula on november 01, 2008
 
   
 
Locals get Political
Who needs pre-made signs? While traveling for a story I found some residents had taken the initiative to create their own.
Tags: election   Choose Or Lose   Connecticut   Street Team '08   street   politic...
Views 7
by  kristendeptula on november 01, 2008
 
   
 
Tattoo the Vote!
Friends gathered at Spirit Gallery, a tattoo studio/art gallery in Franklin, CT to register new voters and get the word out on the importance of voting. You can...
Tags: politics   election   vote   Choose Or Lose   obama   register to vote   grassroots...
Views 506
by  kristendeptula on october 22, 2008
 
   
 
Coming Out in Connecticut
Meet Robin and Kamora, directors at True Colors, one of three organizations nationwide to support and advocate for LGBTQI youth. Hear what they have to say and...
Tags: election   discrimination   Advocacy   Gay   transgender   lesbian   Bisexual...
Views 255
by  kristendeptula on october 02, 2008
 
   
 
CT Republican Takes Lead as Chief Page...
Jake Bookwalter is an unlikely Republican. Raised in a family of Democrats, Bookwalter left the party in 2004 to work on George W. Bush's reelection campaign, and...
Tags: election   Choose Or Lose   John McCain   Democrats   George W. Bush   Republicans...
Views 118
by  kristendeptula on august 28, 2008
 
   
 
Iowa Smoking Ban Fair?
State Rep. Janet Peterson is the main sponsor of the Iowa Smokefree Air Act, which went into effect on Tuesday. Jeff Wagner is a bar manager who feels the government...
Tags: smoking   election   Choose Or Lose   health   Iowa   Street Team 08   ban   ...
Views 58
by  NathanLeigh on july 02, 2008
 
   
 
Supreme Civil Liberties
On Monday I decided to hang out around the steps of the Supreme Court and ask our peers what they thought about civil liberties. You've heard a lot about them in...
Tags: politics   war   washington dc   MTV News   Iraq   Guantanamo Bay   justice   ...
Views 167
by  EricaAmerica on may 07, 2008
 
   
 
VLOG: Atlantic City's Smoking Ban: Savi...
Street Team Correspondent Sia Nyorkor dishes on the new law that would ban smoking in all 11 of Atlantc City's casinos.
Tags: smoking   New Jersey   Choose Or Lose   law   Street Team '08   Sia Nyorkor...
Views 90
by  SiaNyorkor_NJ on may 01, 2008
 
   
 
Lance isn't Smoking
Lance Armstrong visits Madison and Milwaukee this week to promote a state wide smoking ban. Though the issue attracts bipartisan support, not everyone is on board...
Tags: smoking   Democrats   Republicans   wisconsin   rights   Street Team 08   Milwaukee...
Views 267
by  CharlieB on march 06, 2008
 
 
News
 
 
 
   
 
by  MTVNews
The California Supreme Court has decided it will review challenges to Proposition 8, which bans...
 
   
 
by  thinkMTV
A rep for Chris Brown denied that he is responsible for leaking racy photographs of a woman who ...
 
 
Groups
 
 
 
   
 
Organized by  thinkMTV
Meet Fatman Scoop and his wife Shanda- in their new MTV series they answer all your most em...
 
   
 
Organized by  queenbee103912
A group where teens can discuss love and sex issues or questions they have. Anything can b...