NEWS:  Iraq-War Vets Call Hillary Clinton's 'Misspoken' Bosnia Comments 'Insulting'
 
 
Hillary Clinton meets with eight young veterans
Photo: Jeff Fusco/Getty Images
Mar 26, 2008 07:08 AM
Iraq-war veterans criticized Hillary Clinton's "misspoken" comments describing arriving in Bosnia under sniper fire in 1996.
from  MTVNews
By  Bernard Lumpkin

Jessica McDermott, who served in Iraq as a medical officer, was in Pennsylvania last week, participating in "Choose or Lose Presents: Clinton & Obama Answer Young Veterans," when she first heard about Senator Hillary Clinton's "misspoken" description of arriving under sniper fire at the Tuzla Air Base in Bosnia in 1996, which in recent days has become a black eye for the presidential candidate.

"As a combat veteran," McDermott said, "I feel that it is insulting that a politician would use their one- or two-day trip to a combat zone to relate to veterans."

So it should come as no surprise that McDermott, along with several other young Iraqi veterans who were participating in the forum with her, were even more insulted by Clinton's subsequent claims that she misspoke after video footage surfaced this week showing the senator's entourage exiting the rear of their cargo plane and walking calmly across the tarmac in Bosnia.

"I wasn't impressed," said Chris Weimer, 26, a Marine Corps sergeant who received a Purple Heart for wounds received while fighting in Iraq. "It seemed like a play to make herself seem like something she isn't: an American with the courage to risk the ultimate sacrifice for his or her country. She wanted to make it seem like she knew what it was like living in the same danger our troops face every day in places like Iraq and Afghanistan.

"That angered me, because there is no way anyone can understand what it's like to live in a place where your life is at risk every second of every day unless you actually take the same risks your combat troops do."

Other veterans who participated in the forum share his feelings. "The speech was merely a [sensationalized] attempt at gaining legitimacy," said Ryan Groves, 27, a Marine who lost his left leg in combat. "I don't blame Hillary for trying to play that card, for she is a woman who is attempting to be the first female commander in chief of the world's most powerful military in the history of the world."

The young vets had largely positive comments regarding their interaction with Clinton during MTV's forum.

The reactions of these young veterans demonstrate the slippery slope that politicians walk when they use combat-zone trips to earn respect from those who might otherwise be skeptical of their experience in military matters. "Candidates obviously need to make a strong position on understanding what it means to serve in the military and, more importantly, serve the military in a time of war," Weimer said. "However, making false statements about being under sniper fire is definitely not convincing anyone that she has either the credibility or appreciation for what it is America's military lives with every day they are in a combat zone."

And with the next major Democratic primary in Pennsylvania less than a month away, young veterans are one group that Clinton is having trouble winning over in the battle for credibility on military matters. In town-hall speeches and televised commercials, the senator has tried to paint herself as having the foreign-policy experience to be a strong leader on the world stage. But whether or not she misspoke, the senator's Bosnia remarks are being viewed as an attempt to trump up her experience abroad as first lady in contrast to her rival for the Democratic nomination, Senator Barack Obama.

So how should politicians show their support for the troops without diminishing the experiences of those who are actually fighting in combat? The vets we spoke with point to John McCain, who visited the Shorja market in Baghdad last April as part of a congressional delegation that was heavily protected by U.S. soldiers and helicopters.

"I was impressed by Senator McCain's trip to Baghdad," said McDermott. "First of all, he is a combat veteran, so it is not surprising that he was out of the Green Zone. And he was in his 'battle rattle,' which showed that he was conscious of the dangers around him, and which served as a good role model for soldiers." McDermott added that VIPs frequently travel to combat zones at night, when it is safer. So even though McCain wore body armor and was heavily protected, he still showed his solidarity with the troops. "I was just glad to hear that he was walking around in the daytime," she said, "security detail or not."

Weimer cited Senator McCain's recent trip to the Middle East as further evidence of his ability to win the kind of support of troops and veterans that has eluded Senator Clinton. "John McCain has proven in the past that he has been to [Iraq's] ground zero, and now has reminded us that he is not afraid to go back."

After watching "Choose or Lose Presents Clinton & Obama Answer Young Veterans,"head here for additional material, including profiles of the Iraq veterans featured in the show.

 
 
Rate This
0 Ratings
Take Action On
 
 
Tags: iraq war   Iraq   Hillary Clinton   Vets   Bosnia   veterans
Views: 3678    Favorited: 0
URL:
 
 
 You are not logged in. Log In or Sign Up
Post a Comment
shaunatea 492 days ago
this is scaring the **** out of me, obama is way too smooth for me to trust him. i think that its the end of the world as we know it. the signs are everywhere, and it says that before the end comes, there will be "peace worldwide", meaning that everything will seem nice and there will be a world wide religion that is being accepted but really being led by the devil. i think this crap is a whole lot more behind it then it looks to the eye. we need some serioud changes immediatley but noone wants to go thru the uncomfort of dramatic change, lets see how we like it when its force on us, we're fu*ked.
shaunatea 492 days ago
why are they talking sh*t about her for trying to see whats going on out there, at least she had the balls to even go, alot of politicians wouldnt even o that. Yeah, so she didnt wanna be front line, doesnt make her insensative and it damn well doesnt mean that she doesnt care or know what its like. so what politician now a days has been in the military, any branch? cant name one can you, cuz its not the 1800s anymore and they dont need to prove thier loyalty by doing it, that was sumthing extra she did and should be commended for, GOOD JOB WOMAN!!! At least you put in an effort, more then our current prez does. im suprized that guys who are at war and go through all this training to make themselves tough would ***** so much, like lil bitches, especiallly those who are "patriotic", ridiculous, they need to stop acting so sensative cuz theyre coming off as whiners, damn liberals.
Related Media
 
See all related
 
   
 
1 Of 7: Making Their Voices Heard
The veterans and presidential candidates meet in Scranton, Pennsylvania. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Barack Obama   Hillary Clinton   veterans   Withdrawal...
Views 4922
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
2 Of 7: Why I Joined The Military
The vets tell Senator Obama their reasons for enlisting, and Wendell talks about his experience with post-traumatic stress disorder. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Barack Obama   veterans   Post-Tramatic Stress Disorder
Views 5051
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
3 Of 7: Problems Back Home
Returning to civilian life sometimes means PTSD, homelessness and stop-lossing. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Barack Obama   veterans   homelessness   Post-Tramatic Stress Disorder...
Views 4901
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
4 Of 7: Getting The Troops Out
Obama explains his plan for withdrawal, but Chris gives a real-life example involving Fallujah that proves it isn't easy. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Fallujah   Military   Barack Obama   veterans   Withdrawal
Views 4893
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
5 Of 7: The Things They Carried
The vets show Senator Clinton the mementos that got them through hard times and express concern over inadequate military training. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Hillary Clinton   soldiers   Training   veterans
Views 4905
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
6 Of 7: Finish What You Start?
Most of the veterans agree with Clinton's plan for a 60-day withdrawal, but Ryan isn't convinced. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Hillary Clinton   veterans   Withdrawal
Views 4870
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
7 Of 7: Heroes At Home
After withdrawing troops, Clinton says she would transfer war funding to programs that would get vets the help they need. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Hillary Clinton   soldiers   Training   veterans   Heroes...
Views 4879
by  MTVNews on march 21, 2008
 
   
 
What Will It Take To Bring Soldiers Home?
Soldiers bring their issues to the Democratic presidential hopefuls in "Choose or Lose Presents Obama & Clinton Answer Young Veterans," airing Thursday at 6 p.m...
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   Military   mtvU   conflict   soldiers   Choose Or Lose...
Views 4429
by  MTVNews on march 19, 2008
 
   
 
'Words And Action Are Two Different Th...
The vets liked Clinton's conviction, but many are waiting to reserve judgment until she's in office. (3.20.08)
Tags: MTV Think   mtvU   Barack Obama   Hillary Clinton   veterans   Choose Or Lose...
Views 4450
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'I Like The Guy, But It's A Tough Job'
The soldiers thought Obama had a complete plan and that he was honest, even when he was saying what they didn't want to hear. (3.20.08)
Tags: MTV Think   mtvU   Barack Obama   Hillary Clinton   veterans   Choose Or Lose...
Views 4461
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'I Really Believe Hope ... Watched Over Me'
Max Nitze, 23, explains how his fiancee (and a tattoo in her honor) helped him through his two deployments. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Choose Or Lose Presents Obama...   ...
Views 4938
by  MTVNews on july 06, 2009
 
   
 
The Race Kicked Off Before Spencer W...
Take a minute to look back at everything that led up to Obama's victory. (11.5.08)
Tags: Jim Cantiello   Barack Obama   Hillary Clinton   Choose Or Lose   Election...
Views 119
by  MTVNews on november 05, 2008
 
   
 
How Can You Be BRAVE?
Young vets explain the five points of the Bill of Rights for American Veterans.
Tags: MTV Think   Military   Choose Or Lose   troops   Brave   Vets   Bill Of Rights...
Views 166
by  MTVNews on october 25, 2008
 
   
 
'I Had A Lot Of Repressed Emotions'
Bryan Adams didn't even know what post-traumatic stress disorder was when he was diagnosed with it after returning from Iraq. (10.24.08)
Tags: MTV Think   Iraq   Brave   veterans   Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder   Bryan...
Views 72
by  MTVNews on october 25, 2008
 
   
 
Student Vets Adjust To Life On Campus
We talk to some George Washington University students who are making the transition from soldier to civilian. (10.22.08)
Tags: MTV Think   students   Choose Or Lose   Tim Kash   Brave   veterans   Bill Of...
Views 105
by  MTVNews on october 21, 2008
 
   
 
The Economy And Young Americans
Obama says the bailout affects everyone, "especially the next generation." (9.27.08)
Tags: election   MTV News   Barack Obama   John McCain   joe biden   veterans   sarah...
Views 49
by  MTVNews on september 27, 2008
 
   
 
Obama Shrugs Off John McCain's Debat...
The Illinois senator doesn't seem fazed by his rival's claims that he doesn't understand the issues. (9.27.08)
Tags: election   MTV News   Barack Obama   John McCain   joe biden   veterans   sarah...
Views 89
by  MTVNews on september 27, 2008
 
   
 
Taking Care Of Vets Is 'Non-Negotiable'
Obama says the biggest problem facing veterans is that they're forgotten. (9.27.08)
Tags: election   MTV News   Barack Obama   John McCain   joe biden   veterans   sarah...
Views 66
by  MTVNews on september 27, 2008
 
   
 
'I Wasn't Fighting Against Muslims; I Was...
Shama partly joined the Marine Corps to prove that he was "American now." (8.8.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV News   MTV Think   armed forces   Muslim-American   Ahmed Shama...
Views 37
by  MTVNews on august 08, 2008
 
   
 
'I Lost All The Love In My Heart'
Meet Lorenzo, an Iraq war vet who struggles with his memories of combat and then gets the surprise of his life. (7.25.08)
Tags: iraq war   Sway   Kanye West   Choose Or Lose   Homecoming   Vets   veterans...
Views 1493
by  MTVNews on july 28, 2008
 
 
News
 
 
 
   
 
by  MTVNews
We outline the duties of the secretary of state, following the news of Hillary Clinton's nominatio...
 
   
 
by  MTVNews
50 Cent performed for veterans at "A Night For Vets: An MTV Concert For The BRAVE," and sa...
 
 
Groups
 
 
 
   
 
Organized by  Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW)
Women are veterans, too. Show all of our women who are serving, or who have ever served, h...
 
   
 
Organized by  thinkMTV
This group, made possible through the generous support of the McCormick Foundation, is your p...
 
 
Blog posts