NEWS:  Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton Sit Down With Iraq Vets To Address Post-War Illness, Exit Strategies And More For MTV Forum
 
 
Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama speak to soldiers at "Choose or Lose Presents Clinton & Obama Answer Young Veterans"
Photo: MTV News
Mar 18, 2008 08:57 AM
Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton sat down with veterans to address post-war illness, exit strategies and more for an MTV forum, which premieres Thursday.
from  MTVNews
By  Robert Mancini

Senators Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton came face-to-face with the all-too-young veterans of the Iraq war this week, sitting down with eight servicemen and -women as part of an MTV News dialogue.

Some wanted answers about our purpose in Iraq. Some demanded action on life after service. But all brought their issues directly to the candidates over the course of an emotional two days.

"It's a real call to action," Clinton said after hearing stories of their struggles — both abroad and at home.

Obama sat down with these young veterans on Monday in Scranton, Pennsylvania, taking a break from canvassing this big-ticket primary state to address these soldiers and their issues. Clinton then greeted the young vets a couple of hours south in Lancaster on Tuesday, just before resuming her push for a Keystone State primary win. In Scranton, the scene was Whistle's sports bar, March Madness coverage droning on in one room, while these young soldiers aired their issues in the next. In Lancaster, it was the sprawling brewpub the Lancaster Brewing Company (less than an hour before a wedding reception took over the restaurant's back room). While the settings were different, concerns about physical, mental and transitional care for veterans were constant (fitting, with seven of these eight young veterans dealing with post-traumatic stress disorder). In a particularly emotional moment with Obama, decorated vet Wendell Guillermo said his medals did little to make up for life with PTSD. "I would trade in my Purple Heart to get my life back to as normal as it can be," Guillermo said.

"Frankly, one of the problems of this war has been the lowballing of the cost of caring for our vets," Obama acknowledged. He pledged that all vets would be screened for PTSD within 30 days of returning from combat and noted that the stigma that surrounds PTSD, and all mental illnesses, is a roadblock to better treatment and understanding. He also pledged to reduce bureaucracy, help family support and provide transitional support.

"The thing that concerns me is that the unemployment rate among these veterans is actually higher than among those who never served," Obama said.

Clinton also called for additional support for returning veterans and pointed to a record that includes legislation requiring pre- and post-deployment examinations. "It's still not being used the way I had hoped," she admitted, "but it's on the books."

Pressed by one veteran, Herold Noel, who had also met with the senator in 2005, Clinton noted that she's worked with veterans groups as well as officials on the federal, state and city levels to get homeless vets off the streets. "The reason that I'm running for president is that we need to change from top to bottom," Clinton said. "I've tried to get more money into [Veterans Affairs], tried to get the system to respond to individual cases, and told the city and the state that they have to cut through the red tape. ... I'm not making any excuses, but I am saying there are all of these roadblocks."

She also pledged to fight for additional resources and support and suggested that her exit strategy could help to pay for it.

"When we pull out of Iraq, we'll no longer be spending 10 to 12 billion dollars a month there," she said, noting the need to fully fund the VA.

And, of course, that exit strategy (as well as Obama's) drew plenty of attention as well.

"There are no good solutions in Iraq," Obama said, while advocating an emphasis on diplomacy, humanitarian aid and an increased role for the U.N. "We can stabilize the region. It's not going to be ideal. It's not that we couldn't do what we needed to control Iraq. The question is, should we continue doing it?"

Clinton echoed a similar sentiment, lauding the troops for their heroism but noting that the time to bring them home has come.

"The Iraqis have been given the greatest gift you can give someone: the gift of freedom," Clinton said. "But we're not going to be able to solve their civil war. They have to solve it. ... We're not going to be here to referee your civil war."

She reiterated her plan to begin troop withdrawals within 60 days of taking office, noting that the time has come for Iraqis to build their own peace. "In my view, the U.S. military did its job. ... I'm just not sure how much more we can do for them."

But beyond policy and promises, these vets also had a chance to share personal stories — tales of bravery, strength and heroism in the face of unimaginable violence and trauma. They even found a few things to laugh about. Recalling his initial decision to enlist, vet Ernest Johnson said, "I wanted to sign up when I was 17, but my mom wouldn't sign me up."

"Yeah, moms are like that," Clinton joked.

And meeting the vets around a pool table, Obama breathed a sigh of relief after sinking the 3-ball into the side pocket, joking, "If I would have missed, it would be all over YouTube."

But more than the one-liners, the veterans appreciated the chance to bring their issues directly to the candidates. "I think it takes a lot of courage to sit down with a bunch of vets," said Ryan Grove, a medically retired Marine who lost a leg and severely damaged his other while serving in Iraq.

"I think that regardless of what happens, the platform we had here will help to spread the word about our issues," vet Chris Weimer added.

 
 
Group
 
   
 
Rate This
9 Ratings
Take Action On
 
 
Tags: Barack Obama   Hillary Clinton   Iraq Vets   Exit Strategies   MTV Forum   Post-War Illness
Views: 3746    Favorited: 9
URL:
 
 
 You are not logged in. Log In or Sign Up
Post a Comment
jessicamcdermott 598 days ago
I cannot say how amazing this experience was. Eight Iraq combat veterans, speaking to Senator Obama and Senator Clinton, and asking real questions that face combat veterans. We let our guards down, shared our stories, and hopefully the questions we asked made an impact on both cadidates. We also hope that America watches the broadcast and reads our blogs. That they listen to what young combat veterans have to say about the war on terror, the presidental election and the needs of our fellow veterans.
josara 597 days ago
hey i really want to watch this. i dont have a tv. where can i watch it online?
ErnestJohnson 590 days ago
after i a sat down and watched the episode a couple of times so i really could sit and think on what the canidates said i noticed that Hilary really didnt answer my question she more or less just reinerated what i said in a different way, do any of you other guys feel the same way?
Related Media
 
See all related
 
   
 
1 Of 7: Making Their Voices Heard
The veterans and presidential candidates meet in Scranton, Pennsylvania. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Barack Obama   Hillary Clinton   veterans   Withdrawal...
Views 4922
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
2 Of 7: Why I Joined The Military
The vets tell Senator Obama their reasons for enlisting, and Wendell talks about his experience with post-traumatic stress disorder. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Barack Obama   veterans   Post-Tramatic Stress Disorder
Views 5051
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
3 Of 7: Problems Back Home
Returning to civilian life sometimes means PTSD, homelessness and stop-lossing. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Barack Obama   veterans   homelessness   Post-Tramatic Stress Disorder...
Views 4901
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
4 Of 7: Getting The Troops Out
Obama explains his plan for withdrawal, but Chris gives a real-life example involving Fallujah that proves it isn't easy. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Fallujah   Military   Barack Obama   veterans   Withdrawal
Views 4893
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
5 Of 7: The Things They Carried
The vets show Senator Clinton the mementos that got them through hard times and express concern over inadequate military training. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Hillary Clinton   soldiers   Training   veterans
Views 4905
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
6 Of 7: Finish What You Start?
Most of the veterans agree with Clinton's plan for a 60-day withdrawal, but Ryan isn't convinced. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Hillary Clinton   veterans   Withdrawal
Views 4870
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
7 Of 7: Heroes At Home
After withdrawing troops, Clinton says she would transfer war funding to programs that would get vets the help they need. (3.20.08)
Tags: iraq war   Military   Hillary Clinton   soldiers   Training   veterans   Heroes...
Views 4879
by  MTVNews on march 21, 2008
 
   
 
'Words And Action Are Two Different Th...
The vets liked Clinton's conviction, but many are waiting to reserve judgment until she's in office. (3.20.08)
Tags: MTV Think   mtvU   Barack Obama   Hillary Clinton   veterans   Choose Or Lose...
Views 4450
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'I Like The Guy, But It's A Tough Job'
The soldiers thought Obama had a complete plan and that he was honest, even when he was saying what they didn't want to hear. (3.20.08)
Tags: MTV Think   mtvU   Barack Obama   Hillary Clinton   veterans   Choose Or Lose...
Views 4461
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'He Asked Me To Help Him Open The Bo...
Jessica McDermott, 29, was stationed in Mosul, Iraq, when a suicide bomber targeted her mess hall. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Choose Or Lose Presents Obama...   ...
Views 4936
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'I Didn't Expect To Get Attacked The Firs...
Ernest Johnson, 23, hadn't even been issued a weapon when the airport he was waiting in came under attack. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Choose Or Lose Presents Obama...   ...
Views 4903
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'The Military Was Like A Father Figure In...
"When I joined the military, I got that discipline I needed, I got that courage I needed," Herold Noel, 28, says. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Choose Or Lose Presents Obama...   ...
Views 4861
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'She Was Just A Little Girl Who Was Go...
"I looked at this little girl and I saw her as something pure in the middle of a bunch of chaos," Chris Weimer, 26, says of a child he encountered in Iraq. (3.1...
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Choose Or Lose Presents Obama...   ...
Views 4888
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'Next Thing I Knew, I Was Laying On The...
Ryan Groves, 27, explains how he lost his leg in an explosion. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Ryan Groves   Choose Or Lose Presents...
Views 4900
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'Fortunately, Somebody Came Back For Us'
Cristina Correa, 23, was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder when she got home, but was told that counseling was only available for men. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   cristina correa   Choose Or Lose Presents...
Views 4920
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
'I Really Believe Hope ... Watched Over Me'
Max Nitze, 23, explains how his fiancee (and a tattoo in her honor) helped him through his two deployments. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Choose Or Lose Presents Obama...   ...
Views 4938
by  MTVNews on july 06, 2009
 
   
 
'It Felt Like Time Was Just Frozen'
"I turned around, and one of my buddies yelled out, 'Grenade!' " Wendell Guillermo, 23, recalls of a blast, in which he was injured. (3.19.08)
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   mtvU   soldiers   Choose Or Lose Presents Obama...   ...
Views 4930
by  MTVNews on march 20, 2008
 
   
 
What Will It Take To Bring Soldiers Home?
Soldiers bring their issues to the Democratic presidential hopefuls in "Choose or Lose Presents Obama & Clinton Answer Young Veterans," airing Thursday at 6 p.m...
Tags: iraq war   MTV Think   Military   mtvU   conflict   soldiers   Choose Or Lose...
Views 4429
by  MTVNews on march 19, 2008
 
   
 
The Albers Family House Is Revealed
A home destroyed by Hurricane Katrina is completely renovated and furnished. (1.20.09)
Tags: Sway   Barack Obama   be the change   inauguration   Youth Ball   Huricane...
Views 0
by  MTVNews on january 26, 2009
 
   
 
Thnks fr th Mmrs & America's Suit...
After dedicating "Thnks Fr Th Mmrs" to George W. Bush, the boys play "America's Suitehearts" for the Obamas. (1.20.09)
Tags: Fall Out Boy   Sway   Barack Obama   be the change   inauguration   Youth Ball
Views 4
by  MTVNews on january 22, 2009
 
 
News
 
 
 
   
 
by  thinkMTV
President Barack Obama's joke about the Special Olympics on "The Tonight Show with Jay Leno"...
 
   
 
by  MTVNews
President Barack Obama's inauguration was celebrated by Kanye West, Fall Out Boy and mo...
 
 
Groups
 
 
 
   
 
Organized by  Michelle_Obama
Dedicated to volunteering and community activism to brain storm ideas on Michelle Obama and Barac...
 
   
 
Organized by  thinkMTV
The first joint appearance of Presidential nominees John McCain and Barack Obama addresses the...